Effective questioning is a fundamental tool in secondary education that promotes engagement, fosters critical thinking, and enhances student understanding. Drawing on the insights of educational experts such as Ross Morrison McGill, Tom Sherrington, and researchers like Bjork and Bjork, as well as contemporary studies, this will examine how questioning, when used strategically, can shape a dynamic and inclusive learning environment.
Understanding the Role of Effective Questioning
Effective questioning is not merely about posing inquiries to students; it is a deliberate teaching technique that encourages deeper thought and reflection. According to Ross Morrison McGill, well-crafted questions can stimulate curiosity and spark engagement, pushing students to explore ideas and think critically. Similarly, Tom Sherrington emphasises the role of questioning as a formative assessment tool, giving teachers valuable insights into their students’ understanding in real time. By asking the right kinds of questions, teachers can assess student comprehension, address misconceptions, and guide learners toward deeper intellectual engagement.
The work of Robert Bjork and Elizabeth Bjork also highlights the importance of "desirable difficulties" in learning. They emphasise that when students are challenged through questioning that requires retrieval and application of knowledge, learning becomes more durable. This aligns with the broader goal of effective questioning: not just testing surface-level understanding but deepening students' cognitive processes through retrieval practice, fostering long-term retention.
Similarly, John Hattie's meta-analyses of education research underscore the powerful impact of questioning and formative assessment. Hattie’s work, particularly his concept of ‘visible learning’, shows that formative assessment through questioning has an effect size of 0.90, making it one of the most effective strategies in promoting student achievement.
Key Types of Questions and Their Purpose
1. Open-ended questions: These are questions that cannot be answered with a simple "yes" or "no." Starting with prompts like “Why,” “How,” or “What if,” these questions encourage students to think critically, analyse, and reflect on their learning. Open-ended questions are particularly effective for promoting discussion, encouraging multiple viewpoints, and fostering creative problem-solving.
2. Closed-ended questions: Although often seen as less engaging, closed-ended questions are important for checking foundational knowledge and ensuring students grasp essential facts, not to mention inclusion: for learners who find their lessons more challenging, this question type can allow them to participate and build confidence before moving on to more higher order tasks. Moreover, these questions are useful early in the learning process in a more universal sense, where structure and clarity are needed to confirm basic understanding before moving to more complex topics.
3. Probing questions: These are follow-up questions designed to push students to think more deeply about their responses. When a student gives an answer, the teacher may ask, “Can you explain further?” or “What evidence supports your idea?” Probing questions encourage students to reconsider their answers and think more critically about the subject matter.
4. Think-Pair-Share: This strategy involves giving students time to think individually about a question, then discussing their ideas with a partner before sharing with the class. It promotes individual accountability, collaboration, and enhances participation by allowing students to refine their ideas before speaking in front of the group.
5. Say It Again, Better (or Differently): This technique encourages students to rephrase or improve their initial responses, refining their ideas and learning to express themselves more clearly. It promotes active reflection and metacognitive awareness, helping students think about how they communicate their understanding.
6. Cold Calling: In this strategy, the teacher calls on students to answer questions whether or not they volunteer. This can be an effective way to maintain engagement and ensure that all students are thinking about the material, not just the most vocal. When used thoughtfully, cold calling can create an inclusive learning environment where every student is expected to participate.
7. Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs): While often associated with standardised testing, well-crafted MCQs can also be used formatively in the classroom. These questions can check understanding quickly and reveal common misconceptions, providing immediate feedback to both the teacher and students.
Show-Me Boards: The Golden Ticket
Show-me boards, also known as mini whiteboards, are an effective tool for ensuring active participation in the classroom. Each student is provided with a small board on which they can write their answers to a question posed by the teacher. This method promotes inclusivity as every student must engage with the question, rather than only a few vocal participants. Additionally, it ensures that teachers can gauge the understanding of the entire class at once, rather than relying on individual responses.
Show-me boards are also an inclusive practice that allows all students to contribute, including those who may be reluctant to speak out in front of the whole class. This simple tool ensures that every student is accountable and that the teacher has a complete picture of student understanding. The boards offer immediate feedback, making it easier to identify and address misconceptions or gaps in learning as they arise. Moreover, it creates a more equitable learning environment where students who are less confident or who need additional time to process their thoughts can still participate actively without the pressure of public speaking.
Questioning as a Tool for Formative Assessment
Effective questioning plays a critical role in formative assessment. By integrating questions into daily instruction, teachers can assess student understanding and identify gaps in knowledge. For example, open-ended questions can reveal how deeply students have grasped a concept, while closed-ended questions can check for specific factual understanding. Probing questions, meanwhile, can uncover student misconceptions or areas where more explanation is needed.
Formative assessment through questioning allows teachers to tailor their instruction to the needs of their students. Rather than waiting until the end of a unit or lesson to assess understanding, questioning provides ongoing feedback. This aligns with research by Black and Wiliam (1998), which emphasises the importance of formative assessment in enhancing student learning outcomes.
Building Metacognitive Skills and Promoting Peer Learning
Effective questioning also helps develop students' metacognitive skills—the ability to monitor and regulate their own thinking. When students are challenged with thought-provoking questions, they are encouraged to think about how they are learning and to reflect on the strategies they use to arrive at an answer. This process of self-reflection and adjustment is essential for long-term learning and intellectual growth.
Bjork and Bjork’s work on learning and memory also underscores the significance of such practices in improving long-term retention. Their research on the benefits of retrieval practice suggests that when students are asked to retrieve information through questioning, the act of recalling strengthens their memory of that information. This adds another layer of value to effective questioning, as it not only helps gauge current understanding but also enhances retention for the future.
Additionally, questioning promotes peer learning. Techniques like Think-Pair-Share or group discussions encourage students to articulate their thinking and listen to the perspectives of others. This not only deepens individual understanding but also fosters a collaborative learning environment where students learn from one another.
Insights from Research and Strategies for Improvement
Current research offers several strategies to enhance the effectiveness of questioning in the classroom:
Wait-Time: Research by Rowe (1974) shows that providing students with more time to think before answering a question leads to better, more thoughtful responses. Teachers should be mindful of giving students enough time to process questions before expecting answers.
Question Planning: Teachers should thoughtfully plan questions in alignment with learning objectives. This ensures that the questions are purposeful and designed to target specific levels of cognitive development, whether recalling facts, analysing concepts, or applying knowledge to new situations.
Variety in Question Types: To engage all students, it is important to vary question types. A mixture of open, closed, probing, and higher-order questions ensures that different learning needs are met, and students are continuously challenged.
Reflective Practice: Teachers should regularly reflect on their questioning techniques and seek feedback from peers and students. This continuous cycle of reflection and refinement is key to improving questioning skills over time.
Conclusion
Effective questioning is a powerful pedagogical tool that can transform classroom dynamics, promote critical thinking, and enhance student learning. When used thoughtfully, it provides a means of formative assessment, fosters metacognitive awareness, and creates an inclusive environment where all students can engage meaningfully with the material. By embracing diverse questioning strategies, teachers can cultivate a classroom culture that encourages inquiry, reflection, and intellectual growth. Drawing on the insights of thinkers like Bjork and Bjork, and John Hattie, we see that questioning not only shapes current learning but also has long-term benefits for knowledge retention and student achievement.
The Conduit team is passionate about what we do. We want to support our colleagues, providing resources that are relevant and indispensable to you. However, we do need to know how best to deliver that for you. You can do that by sending User Requests to us so that we know what kind of resources you need or are missing from your collection. You can interact with us on our Social Media channels:
Instagram: Conduit_Connecting_Knowledge
Twitter: @ConduitScotEdu
Comments